Some of our ancestors were early colonists, but many came to America just a few generations ago from England, Scotland, Ireland, Germany, and the Netherlands. So it is no surprise that our lineage can be traced back to the area in and around New York City.
Fort Lee, NJ keeps coming up as a common place of origin, particularly on my father's side. Thomas Whitfield came from England, married Betsy Godfrey from Providence RI, and settled in New York. Their daughter Sarah married John Abbott from Newark, NJ. The Abbotts' son Whitfield married Sadie Wright from Brooklyn and settled in Fort Lee. Their son, my great grandfather, George Abbott, was born there.
Orrin Bishop Judd, my dad's paternal ancestor from Hartford, Connecticut, lived in Brooklyn at different times in his life and married Elizabeth MacDonald from Bronx, NY. My mother's great grandmother, Miriam Olivia Wandell, was born in Brooklyn of parents with a Dutch heritage.
I have always felt a draw to that part of the world, especially to Long Island and Rhode Island. Never thought much about New Jersey, but it's looking more and more interesting now.